Cincinnati's Best Thrift, Vintage, & Consignment Shops - Wander Cincinnati (2024)

Everyone loves a good deal on clothing, furniture, and other household items. And there’s no better place to score some great deals than thrift stores, vintage stores, and consignment shops, which all sell lightly used items at steep discounts.

Fortunately for those of us in Cincinnati, there are plenty of these types of stores sprinkled throughout the city.

From curated clothing shops to massive thrift stores to vintage furniture outlets, we’ve got it all.

In this post, we share the best thrift stores, vintage stores, and consignment shops worth checking out around the Queen City.

Map of Shops

The map below shows the locations of every shop mentioned in this post.

Vintage Clothing

Casablanca Vintage:A vintage clothing store in Northside that offers an impressive variety of vintage shirts, shoes, dresses, and more.

Pixel 19:A vintage store located in East Price Hill selling all things vintage including clothing, accessories, jewelry, collectibles, and more.

Mannequin Boutique:A thrift shop in Over-The-Rhine that offers both designer & vintage clothing & accessories for men & women. Best of all, they donate their proceeds to local charities.

NVISION:A vintage clothing store in Northside that offers a wide variety of vintage clothing, purses, shoes, jewelry, coats, and some furniture. The staff is friendly and the prices are reasonable.

Portaluca:A women’s clothing store in Downtown Cincinnati that seeks to “provide quality fashion at affordable prices, helping women to feel confident, optimistic, and beautiful.”Best of all, proceeds benefit Dress for Success Cincinnati to help women achieve economic independence.

Hi-Bred:A hip vintage clothing store in Northside offering a curated selection of vintage & modern clothing, housewares & crafts.

Vintage Marketplace: A women’s clothing store selling vintage clothing and jewelry for excellent prices. They have one location in Montgomery and another in Hyde Park.

Talk of the Town:A spacious, eclectic store in Reading selling an extensive selection of vintage clothing, costumes & accessories.

Vintage Furniture

Riverside Centre Antique Mall:An antique mall in Columbia-Tusculum featuring over 100 vendors selling a huge variety of antiques. Prices range from dirt cheap to somewhat expensive. This is a great place to find some vintage furniture and it’s a place where you can spend several hours strolling through the different vendors.

Leftcoast Modern: A vintage furniture store in Over-The-Rhine that curates decorative modern furniture and objects of art that can be used in both homes and businesses.

Mainly Art Vintage Furnishings: A vintage store in Oakley that offers vintage home furnishings including art, furniture, lighting fixtures, and more. The owners are friendly and knowledgeable, and the shop itself is well maintained.

Astute Furnishings: A shop in Oakley that offers beautiful and unique vintage furniture. The staff is knowledgeable and you can often find great deals on furniture here that are sold at a fraction of the price as placed like Crate & Barrel.

Florence Antique Mall:A massive antique mall in Florence, KY that offers a variety of antique items including furniture, artwork, and collectibles.

Building Value:A resale store in Northside offering used & antique doors, windows, bath & kitchen fixtures & appliances.

Recycle Cincinnati:A store in Silverton that sells antique, vintage, and refinished furniture, art, trinkets, books, and other collectibles.

Tim’s Picks:A retail vintage collectibles shop in Over-The-Rhine offering a variety of vintage mid-century items including furniture, pottery, art prints, posters, original art, clothing, stereo equipment, jewelry and more.

Consignment Shops

Legacies Upscale Resale:A consignment shop in Hyde Park offering vintage furniture, lighting fixtures, jewelry, home accessories, and artwork for reasonable prices.

Snooty Fox:A consignment shop offering luxury and designer brands Women, Men’s, and Children’s clothing along with furniture and home decor. They have locations in Hyde Park, Blue Ash, Montgomery, and Mariemont.

Julie’s Inspiration Consignment Shoppe:A consignment shop located in Covington, KY that sells apparel, jewelry, art, furniture, collectibles, and more.

The Lord’s Bounty:A consignment shop in College Hill offering both modern and vintage women’s and men’s clothing, shoes, accessories, housewares, small electronics, and jewelry.

Thrift Stores

Valley Thrift:A massive thrift store in Evendale featuring clothing, shoes, accessories, and household accessories all at fairly cheap prices. This store is exactly what pops into your head when you think of the word thrift store –tons of lightly worn clothing or lightly used items on sale for great prices.

Tri-County Goodwill Store: A large thrift store in Woodlawn offering excellent deals on a variety of clothing, furniture, and household items.

New2You Uptown Thrift Store:A thrift store in Clifton Heights that specializes in gently used furniture and vintage clothing.

Oakley Goodwill Store:A smaller goodwill thrift store in Oakley also offering excellent deals on clothing, furniture, and household items.

Westwood St. Vincent de Paul Thrift Store:A large thrift store in Westwood offering great deals on clothing, furniture, collectibles, accessories, and other household items.

Note:There are more thrift store locations throughout Cincinnati. We simply listed our favorites in this post. To find a complete list of thrift store locations, check out the following links:

Cincinnati Goodwill Locations

Cincinnati Salvation Army Locations

Cincinnati St. Vincent de Paul Thrift Store Locations

57 Shares

Cincinnati's Best Thrift, Vintage, & Consignment Shops - Wander Cincinnati (2024)

FAQs

What's the best day to go thrifting? ›

While there's no “perfect” day to shop second hand stores, many regulars swear by shopping early on Monday and Tuesday. Homeowners tend to drop off garage sale leftovers on Sunday nights, making for new finds. Plus, the weekends are more crowded shopping days, so employees look to restock early in the week.

How do you find rare and valuable items at thrift stores? ›

How Can You Spot Valuables in a Thrift Store?
  1. Check for Designer Labels or Tags. Valuable vintage items, like clothing, kitchenware or records, often come with a label indicating that it's valuable. ...
  2. Go for Unique Items. ...
  3. Check the Locked Display Case.
Jul 10, 2023

How to bargain at thrift store? ›

Thrift store prices are low, but that doesn't mean they can't go lower. If you think something is priced too high for what is, ask if they're willing to take less for it. Just be polite in doing so and don't be discouraged if they're not open to bargaining.

What is the thrifting capital of the United States? ›

New York, NY

What is the cheapest day to go to Goodwill? ›

According to Goodwill, the perfect time slot to shop at thrift stores is in the morning on both Monday and Tuesday. This is because, at least as far as Goodwill is concerned, people tend to donate garage sale remnants on Sunday, so the pickings are new and fresh come early weekdays.

Why is thrifting so expensive now? ›

“Firstly, the cost of operations — including rent, utilities and wages — has increased over time. Secondly, the quality and brand of donated items can also influence pricing. High-end brands or items in excellent condition may be priced higher.

What is the most valuable item to collect? ›

What Are the Most Valuable Types of Collectibles?
  1. Vintage Comic Books. Comic books are one of the most popular collectibles because of how much they can appreciate in value over time. ...
  2. Baseball Cards. ...
  3. Vintage Bakeware. ...
  4. Rare Coins. ...
  5. Vintage Toys. ...
  6. Stamps. ...
  7. Vintage Magazines. ...
  8. Antique Furniture.
Aug 21, 2023

What sells the most in thrift stores? ›

Clothing. Clothing is an item that sells best in thrift stores. Accounting for 31.8 percent of industry revenue, clothing is the largest revenue generator in the Thrift Stores industry, according to IBISWorld. Instead of paying higher retail prices, many people are switching to thrift stores for their clothing needs.

What is the most valuable thing to look for in a thrift store? ›

How do you know if something is valuable at a thrift store? Look for brand names, quality materials, and vintage items. Research online to determine the value of unusual or antique finds.

What is thrift flipping? ›

Thrift store flipping is the process of purchasing items from a thrift store and then reselling them for a higher price. Thrift stores often sell items for less than their market value, which allows you to capitalize on the difference between the selling price and the market price when flipping items.

How to thrift shop like a pro? ›

10 tips for thrifting
  1. Create a budget. ...
  2. Clear out your closet in between trips to the thrift store. ...
  3. Keep hygiene in mind when giving away or looking for clothes. ...
  4. Get inspiration to help you pick the best items for you. ...
  5. Know what each store specializes in selling. ...
  6. Thrift with a friend. ...
  7. Wear something comfortable.
Mar 16, 2023

Why do thrift stores not have dressing rooms? ›

Why are fitting rooms closed? Keeping fitting rooms open, and maintained, requires additional staffing and expenses that we are not equipped to manage.

What is the best city to thrift in? ›

According to our data, the top five cities for thrifting in the U.S. are Riverside, CA, Atlanta, GA, Columbus, OH, Orlando, FL, and Tampa, FL.

What are the best times of the year to go thrifting? ›

Spring and summer {big moving months} are also great times to thrift, but the end of year also provides a financial reason to give. When you donate clothing, you're eligible for a tax write-off and many people are scurrying to get those tax receipts before the calendar year is out.

What is the best day for shopping? ›

Wednesday is the best day of the week to go grocery shopping because stores are usually less crowded mid-week. For the freshest items, time your shop for store opening or closing.

How do I get the most out of thrifting? ›

Thrifting for the first time? Experts share their tips and tricks.
  1. 1Where you thrift matters.
  2. 2Consider estate sales.
  3. 3Avoid fast fashion.
  4. 4Hit the denim section.
  5. 5Assess leather goods for quality.
  6. 6Look for cool T-shirts and sweatshirts.
  7. 7Check the 'go-back' rack.
Jul 11, 2023

Is thrifting better than buying new? ›

Thrifting benefits not only the environment but also consumers. Here are ways you can benefit by participating in thrifting. Save money: You can save money by purchasing secondhand clothing. Thrift stores often have much lower prices than buying new items.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Nicola Considine CPA

Last Updated:

Views: 6694

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (69 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Nicola Considine CPA

Birthday: 1993-02-26

Address: 3809 Clinton Inlet, East Aleisha, UT 46318-2392

Phone: +2681424145499

Job: Government Technician

Hobby: Calligraphy, Lego building, Worldbuilding, Shooting, Bird watching, Shopping, Cooking

Introduction: My name is Nicola Considine CPA, I am a determined, witty, powerful, brainy, open, smiling, proud person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.